What is Mens Rea?
When facing criminal charges, one of the most critical factors in determining guilt is mens rea, a Latin term meaning “guilty mind.”
Mens rea refers to a person’s mental state when committing a crime. In other words, even if an individual commits an act that appears criminal, they may not be guilty under the law if they lack the required mental intent.
In Arizona and across the United States, criminal law distinguishes between individuals who intentionally break the law and those who act mistakenly or negligently. Without mens rea, many crimes cannot be prosecuted successfully because intent is an essential element in proving guilt.
Understanding this concept can help defendants build a strong defense against criminal charges. In this article, we’ll break it down further.
Get Immediate Help from Our Criminal Defense Attorneys.
We are Available to Talk Now.
Or, Continue Reading Below About:
What Does Mens Rea Mean in a Criminal Case?
The Four Levels of Mens Rea
Most crimes require a certain state of mind for a person to be held criminally responsible. The four primary levels of mens rea include:
- Knowingly – The person was aware that they were committing the act and understood its consequences.
- Intentionally – The person acted with a direct purpose to cause a certain outcome.
- Recklessly – The person knew their actions posed a risk but ignored that risk and acted anyway.
- Negligently – The person failed to be aware of a substantial and unjustifiable risk, but without intent.
Each of these mental states plays a significant role in determining whether an act is criminal or simply an unfortunate accident.
Example: Mens Rea in Assault Charges
To illustrate how mens rea works, let’s take a closer look at assault.
- If someone intentionally punches another person in the face during an argument, this is an intentional assault.
- If they throw punches recklessly in a crowded elevator without regard for whom they might hit, this is reckless assault.
- However, if someone gestures while talking and accidentally strikes a colleague, that is considered negligence and not a crime. While the victim may have a civil claim for damages, the person who caused the injury cannot be criminally prosecuted because they lacked the necessary intent for assault.
Why Negligence is Not Always a Crime
Negligence plays a key role in understanding mens rea. While recklessness means someone acted with disregard for danger, negligence is often a mere oversight.
For example, if someone accidentally hits someone while moving their arms during a conversation, they did not intend to cause harm, making it an accident rather than a crime.
However, if they were swinging their arms wildly in a crowd, knowing the potential risk, they could be charged with reckless assault.
Example: Mens Rea in a Shoplifting Charge
Shoplifting, also known as theft, is another example of how intent matters in criminal cases.
- If someone deliberately hides an item under their clothing and walks out of a store without paying, they have committed theft knowingly or intentionally.
- If someone absentmindedly leaves a store while distracted by a phone call and unknowingly takes an item with them, they do not have the required mens rea to be convicted of theft.
- In the second scenario, the person may be stopped by store security, but once they explain that it was an accident and return the item, no crime has been committed.
This example highlights why mistakes and absentminded actions do not always lead to criminal liability.
Why Mens Rea Matters in Criminal Cases
Mens rea is a fundamental principle in criminal law because it helps distinguish between:
- A criminal act and an innocent mistake
- An accident and intentional wrongdoing
- Negligence and reckless disregard for the law
This distinction is crucial in preventing wrongful convictions. If the prosecution cannot prove that the defendant acted with the necessary intent, the charges may be reduced or dismissed altogether.
For example, in driving under the influence cases, Arizona’s strict DUI laws require that the driver either knowingly or recklessly consumed alcohol before getting behind the wheel. If someone was unknowingly given an alcoholic drink and then drove without realizing they were over the legal limit, their defense attorney could argue that they lacked the necessary mens rea for a DUI conviction.
Similarly, in drug possession cases, a person who unknowingly carries illegal substances because they borrowed a friend’s bag without checking its contents may not have the required intent to be convicted of drug possession.
How an Experienced Criminal Defense Attorney Can Help
At Colburn Hintze Maletta, our experienced defense attorneys, including David Maletta, carefully examine every aspect of a case, especially the defendant’s state of mind. Mens rea is one of the most important legal principles in determining guilt, and challenging the prosecution’s evidence on intent can be a powerful defense strategy.
Our defense legal team will work to:
- Prove that the act was accidental and lacked the required mental state for conviction.
- Challenge the prosecution’s evidence on intent and whether the defendant knowingly committed a crime.
- Negotiate reduced charges if the mental state does not match the severity of the charge.
Facing criminal charges can be overwhelming, but having an experienced legal team on your side makes all the difference.
If you or a loved one is facing criminal charges, contact CHM Law today for a free consultation. Understanding your rights and legal defenses can make all the difference in your case.
📞 Call CHM Law at 602-825-2500 or visit our contact page to schedule a consultation.
David Maletta is a widely respected criminal defense attorney with over 23 years of experience and has worked on over 1,000 cases and has successfully won over 100 jury trials. David graduated from Northern Arizona University, Magna Cum Laude in 1993 with a degree in Psychology. Shortly thereafter, he earned his Juris Doctor degree from Seton Hall University School of Law in 1998. He has extensive experience in criminal and DUI matters, homicide, sexually-based offenses, domestic violence, white-collar crimes, and various misdemeanor crimes.
Always Available 24/7 for Legal Help
Schedule an Appointment Today!
Call Us Now to Speak with an Attorney (602) 825-2500
Real Client Reviews
Below are just a few of what our clients have to say!
“They had very clear understanding with great patience”
I love the customer service. They really take their time to provide knowledge and a very clear understanding with great patience.
Monica Scott - Google Review
“Outstanding Family Law Attorney Office”
Outstanding Family Law Attorney Office the team provided exceptional service during a difficult time. Their professionalism, empathy, and expertise in family law were evident from start to finish. They were always responsive and offered clear, practical advice that made navigating my case much easier. I highly recommend them for anyone in need of a trustworthy and skilled family law attorney.
Lisa Carranza - Google Review
“Hiring him was one of the best decisions I’ve ever made”
Hiring Tim was one of the best decisions I’ve ever made. He cared about my case and worked on it on a personal level. I didn’t have to check in often but when I did, it was obvious that he was still working hard. He went out of his way to get facts, evidence, and information that would help my case. When the prosecutor wasn’t doing their job, he made sure that I got the best outcome possible. I would recommend Tim to any of my family and friends with full confidence that they would get a desirable outcome.
Tyler - Avvo Review
“He was amazing every step of the way. Super friendly and professional”
I was extremely happy with having David Maletta represent me. He is one hell of a guy! He was amazing every step of the way. Super friendly and professional. Having him on my side made all the difference in the world. I couldn’t have asked for a better outcome. I recommend him to anyone who is going through a legal struggle. Thank you for all of your hard work!
Chase - Avvo Review
“I was convinced they were the best firm for the job”
After learning my spouse was filing for divorce, I found CHM Law on both Google and Yelp. After my initial consultation, I was convinced they were the best firm for the job. My team of lawyer Judie and paralegal Whitney were incredible, to say the least. They ensured an incredibly smooth process during a very difficult period and obtained a settlement above and beyond my wildest expectations. If I ever get remarried and divorced again, they will be my first call.
Richard Moser - Google Review
“Very Impressive”
Dave was very impressive he helped me a lot with his knowledge and helped me with the process.
Ana Dalay Vega - Google Review
“He set the right expectations. I am happy with the outcome”
David communicated well and gave me upadates every step of the way answered all questions I had and made me feel comfortable with the process, and he set the right expectations. I am happy with the outcome.
Bailey - Avvo Review
“She’s smart, driven, and supportive”
I highly recommend this law firm to anyone going through a family law case. They are awesome. Lauren Bostick was my attorney and she knows how to bring her A-game. She’s smart, driven, and supportive. Even after my case was finalized she has still answered questions for me and has stayed in communication to ensure that all is well. If you hire this firm I hope she is assigned to your case – but you can feel confident with any of the attorneys here. However, Lauren would be who I ask for if I need them again. Thank you Lauren for your support and help through all of my dramatic twists and turns of my case! You did an awesome job!!!!
Jeremy Chinavare - Google Review
“I Can’t express my gratitude enough and how happy I am with his representation”
Complete stud! Can’t express my gratitude enough and how happy I am with Timothy’s representation. Most say to strike when the iron is hot, but Timothy knew how to play it smoothly, held back his cards, and showed them at the right time. Timothy is your man if you want REAL representation and someone who cares about their clients. He is upfront and walks you through the whole process. It takes time to explain what you’re up against and tells you what could be the outcome both ways. He was able to get my EXTREME DUI along with many other charges dropped down to reckless driving with NO JAIL TIME!!!! Huge victory when the prosecutor wouldn’t budge! I hope to never be in trouble again but if I am Timothy is my man!
Robert - Avvo Review
“Their service is very highly professional”
I highly recommend you all here. Their service is very highly professional. They truly run this process as professionals.
Nahima Lemus - Google Review
“They were exceptional from start to finish”
My experience with Colburn Hintze Maletta was exceptional from start to finish. They were very attentive to my concerns and questions. They took the time to explain the legal process clearly and kept me informed at every step. Their professionalism and commitment to achieving the best outcome for me was evident throughout the entire process. I highly recommend this firm to anyone seeking reliable and effective legal representation.
Chimal Lopez - Google Review
“She was passionate and driven when managing my case”
Lauren Bostick assisted me with the child custody case. She was passionate and driven when managing my case. She thinks outside of the box and is determined to serve justice. Lauren and her teammates ensured I was given recourses to manage my case and my personal well-being. She is extremely knowledgeable and caring. I was honored to be represented by her. Due to her work ethic and perseverance, she was able to win my case and get me even more quality time with my son. I will be forever thankful for her help and her team.
D P- Google Review
“He’s the best!!”
Attorney, Tim Hintze, was a godsend to me!! I truly felt like life was over after I was arrested for Super Extreme DUI. This experience was so devastating for me, and I had no idea what to do. Fortunately for me, I contacted Rosenstein Law Group, which assigned Attorney Timothy Hintze to my case. Tim, with his outstanding calming and professional demeanor, eased my fears and anxieties, throughout this extremely stressful process. Tim, being so thorough with every issue of the case, from viewing the police cams to interviews with officers, was able to pinpoint major flaws made, unknowingly by officers, which resulted in my charges being greatly reduced! His focus on every detail, of my arrest, helped to secure specific evidence which resulted in my charges of Super Extreme DUI, to Impaired to the slightest degree charge, with no jail time! I will be forever grateful to Tim for his expertise and knowledge, but mainly for his kind, and understanding nature which helped me survive this very stressful process. I highly recommend Attorney Tim Hintze to all who need a most sincere, professional, and highly knowledgable Attorney! He’s the best!!
Deb - Avvo Review
“The service provided to me was outstanding”
Absolutely amazing! The service provided to me was outstanding. They listened & made sure I was taken care of. I definitely recommend to everyone!
Nautica - Google Review
“Their communication and accessibility was outstanding”
I went through a divorce years ago and never felt confident enough to spend the money and energy in getting custody of my son, nor believe it was possible until I met with Alysa and Whittney at CHM. From beginning to end it was about an 18-month-long process, but it was well worth it and I would recommend them to anyone. I can’t thank them enough. Their communication and accessibility was outstanding. Not only did they give me my son back, but they gave him the best possible chance at life! Aly and Whittney, thank you!!!
Charlie Mic - Google Review
“He actually cares about your life and what’s going on in it”
David Maletta is one of the best in the business, hiring him to represent me was one of my best decisions. He actually cares about your life and what’s going on in it. It’s like talking with a friend except he’s got your court stuff handled on the backend so you won’t even have to lift a finger!
Manny Martinez - Google Review
“We are very grateful for all of his assistance”
Because I was accused of felony DUI, we recruited David Maletta. The case was dropped to a misdemeanor DUI because of David Maletta’s excellent work. David Maletta went above and beyond to significantly improve a terrible situation because he genuinely cared about the case’s result. We are very grateful for all of his assistance. I would strongly suggest David Maletta to anyone facing a DUI offense.
Precilla - Avvo Review
“Their professionalism and dedication were evident in every interaction”
I had an outstanding experience with Colburn Hintze Maletta PLLC. Their team provided expert legal guidance and support throughout my case. They were responsive, thorough, and always kept me informed. Their professionalism and dedication were evident in every interaction, and they navigated the complexities of my situation with skill and efficiency. I am grateful for their expertise and highly recommend Colburn Hintze Maletta PLLC to anyone in need of reliable and effective legal representation.
Devin Farias - Google Review
“He was very thorough and professional all the way through”
Dave Maletta Attorney represented me in a legal matter and he did an excellent job. He was very thorough and professional all the way through. I would highly recommend his services and his firm. He and his firm did an excellent job apprising me every step of the way about what to do what to expect and the legal process. I very much appreciate his help and I would recommend his services and his firm very strongly as I feel I received a high value for the legal services I requested.
Roger Donohue - Google Review
“I actually interviewed 5 potential lawyers and David was the most optimistic of all of them.”
I have nothing but good things to say about my experience working with David Maletta. I was in a very high stress situation facing a pending dui charge. He doesn’t know this but I actually interviewed 5 potential lawyers and David was the most optimistic of all of them. He took over and handled everything, and now I don’t have to live with a dui. Thank you so much for everything! Highly recommend to anyone looking for legal help.